
Yup, it's official Lucky Star Post(tm) time. Like many others I found myself attracted to this series by the alluring Kyoto Animation label. While about five lightyears off course from the previous Haruhi and Key works that I'd come to love KyoAni for, a light-hearted anime seemed like a good change of course and, besides, there wasn't much else to watch.
So, do I like Lucky Star? Is it the greatest slice of life insanity since Azumanga Daioh? Should KyoAni be left to burn in the lowest depths of hell for producing this trash?
I find myself rather lonely in the middle, between the people who denounce this alternatively as fluff or 'not Haruhi 2/Clannad' and the ones who rave over the waterfall of moe. It's a good show for watching during downtime, when you just want to unwind and watch some light stuff rather than Air something that will leave you an emotional wreck. It has its funny moments and the cute moments.
Yet it's nothing that will make you break out in laughter. The topics average in at decent (although, I must say, the food conversation in Episode 1 probably turned many people off), and although I never really cracked up at any of the lines I found myself with a nice smirk for a lot of it.
I think the main problem with Lucky Star is that it's produced by KyoAni. If it was made by any other studio I'm pretty sure it wouldn't be forced into all the comparisons to the Haruhi and the Kanon and all. KyoAni has built up a huge reputation for it's stunning art and perhaps plot skills that sets the bar for all following anime, and that hurts Lucky Star, which is a far departure from the previous works of KyoAni; mind you, not in a bad way.
There's not a whole lot special about Lucky Star at the moment that makes it Top Tier, for me, but I will continue to watch it. Perhaps a little rabidly.
Right about now would be where I launch into a plot summary of this week's Lucky Star episode. But, what's the point? This is Lucky Star we're talking about here. There is no coherent plot, rather a bunch of unconnected scenes strung together in no orderly manner - or at least with no transitions anyway; I have no doubt that the original 4-komas were the same (these are comic strips we're talking about here).
So I've opted for an alternative discussion: a bit o' character speculation. With 4 overly, ungodly moe heroines to this story, who's going to be the fan favorite? Time to analyze the strengths and weaknesses of main characters in...
KyoAni's Next Nagato/Nayuki
And by that I mean the next (moe) character that's ridiculously popular with the fanbase - usually not the central character to the story. And by ridiculously popular, I'm making educated guesses based off the Megatokyo forums and, um, me.
4) Tsukasa Hiiragi: The normal moe
In the process of ranking, I found that picking a last is as hard as picking a first. Maybe it's just because 3 episodes doesn't give me enough time to find someone to hate, or because, well, all these characters are just designed to be annoyingly adorable.

That said, Tsukasa doesn't stand out from the crowd, as she says so herself. She's a rather average girl that comes the closest to the 'clueless naive girl' in this anime. She especially has been marked as the dim bulb in the crowd, especially with the Golden Week saga in episode 2.
This is probably one of her strong points for fanpeoples also, as her cluelessness and clueless look can be really adorable at times, and if you're the type that likes to be superior in knowledge to others, Tsukasa's a pretty low hurdle to jump.
Not to mention the bonus points merited from the ponytail effect.
3) Kagami Hiiragi: The counter-moe
Kagami can be described in fanboy terms as the 'least attractive' of the four main characters here, not in appearance but in character.
This is because she's got what can be described as a bit of an attitude, as opposed to the rather humble Miyuki and the naive Tsukasa. Konata sums it up quite well in the picture above in stating Kagami's not "cut out for cute style."
But this may be what gives Kagami the edge over Tsukasa for 3rd as she appeals to those who like their girls to have a bit of a backbone. Her wit isn't too bad either as in episode 3 where she logic's Konata into a corner over the legality of copying homework (above screenshot); although, arguably, her intelligence can leave a bit to be desired - but that goes for many in this anime.
Kagami will likely get her most appeal out of the tsundere attitude that she seems to assume.
But overall, picking Kagami over Tsukasa or vice versa can be a moot point as most people would rather take the twin package over one individually. Fandom has no shame.
2) Miyuki Takara: The ideal moe

As Konata professes, Miyuki pretty much is the definition of moe. If you had a list of moe options and checked off all the boxes, you'd get Miyuki: Super Moe LE Special Edition Type-R.


List 'em up: We've got clumsy, forgetful, smart (meganekko will be a huge draw), cute, well-proportioned (she is supposedly the largest character in Lucky Star, although the art doesn't seem to emphasize this point), shy, modest, kind, and, uh, pink-haired. What's not to like?
Why does she lose out to Konata?
Mostly this cannot be attributed to any fault of her own. Many fanpeoples, myself included, will find Miyuki to be Number One for any number of reasons.
But, perhaps this perfect amalgamation of characteristics can serve as a detriment too - the anti-faction can find faults from these same characteristics, in the same way people don't like Lucky Star not because of what is it, but what it isn't (Haruhi).
Overall, however, Miyuki loses out in fandom for not being Konata, for Konata is...
1) Konata Izumi: Fourth wall moe
If Miyuki is the definition of moe, Konata is the definition of those who pursue moe. She appeals to the otaku in nearly every fan, being an avid anime-watcher and gamer.
She shares many of the characteristics that these people would have, including a general dislike of work (hello, Golden Week procrastination) and an obsession with collecting things, so on so forth. Girl gamers are a rare breed and so they are pounced on. Rabidly.
Konata's awareness of moe also allows her to broaden her own moe horizons, in a way. Her knowledge of dating sim tropes (see screenshot), among others, may be attractive in a way to people who know much more about anime and games than more mundane subjects, such as math and science. Indeed, her conversations with the less enlightened in Lucky Star (i.e. the other 3) about moe and anime and collecting certainly are amusing.
And plus, despite being a horrible procrastinator, she's actually pretty bright too - cramming pays off for one person at least.
Otaku-ness, brightness, and sharp wit aside, there is one final factor that makes Konata perfect for fans: her height. Let me spell it out: L-O-L-I-C-O-N.
And that is what matters in the serious business of the Internet.
-CCY
4/24/2007
| [+/-] |
Lucky Star 3 (vaguely)- Cherrrrrrrrrry pieeeeeeeeee |
4/23/2007
| [+/-] |
Shuffle! 5 (no more melancholy jokes here) |

Once again, I find my ability to hate anime nullified. As much as the first two episodes of Shuffle! did very little, I find myself hooked to a strangely functional combination of fanservice and plotline. I think it's time for a Shuffle!-athon.
Mind you, I'm blogging these many episodes behind - I've got frameworks for up to episode 10 so far. So if I sound like I know more than I'm supposed to, that's why (but also spoiler issues, too).
We begin with a flashback, and urges to compare it to pretty much any other eroge (don't most have dream sequences). The art seems a bit off compared to normal, which is either me hallucinating or a stylistic choice. Kaede's the focus of this flashback, and she seems to be saying something important that is either getting drowned out or blocked out...
And then Rin wakes up and has an amusing scene where he tries a little too creatively to dodge the fact that he cried out Kaede's name in the dream (right in front of her face). I'd be a little suspicious if I were Kaede, as the last time I remember a cover-up with this much enthusiasm it was Shiki after the wet dream sequence in Tsukihime.
I mean, aliens, seriously? Now we know the bad liar around here.
What would be really interesting though is if the two of them had synchronized dreams, a la Yuuichi/Ayu in Kanon. Maybe it was just suspicious to me about how Kaede dodged the question of her dream.
It's very worrying how dedicated Kaede is to Rin - if I were watching this blind I couldn't see how she would be anything other than dedicated girl...
I didn't quite understand the earthquake scene, although it was a little funny how Kaede and Rin panicked. I suppose it's justified as earthquakes in Japan are common and serious business. Wonder if Primula's prediction and subsequent stoppage of the earthquake meant anything...special powers?
Or maybe it was just an excuse for Kaede to glomp Rin.
In better and worse news, the fanboys are vaguely less eye-searing this time, and they have a decent theme, and they're vaguely funny to boot. Can't imagine the self-esteem crash they would get from being destroyed by the very idols they worship, though XD
This seems to be adding up to be a Kaede episode as we watch her be ignored. A lot. Like, almost like everyone's trying to. I guess if you've got 5 girls in your harem you can let one or two go. Especially if she seems to step aside herself...
Unless she comes back with a box cutter in 15 episodes.
Sometimes I wonder when I missed the entrance exam for the school with the unwieldly proportioned teachers with great dry wit. Sia and Megumi's reactions were priceless too.
Now if I had more of a critical thinking mind I could analyze the hidden depths of Nerine's quote. So basically if her feelings are like a muddled, soft omelette, then her feelings are confused, mixed up, and very...em, squishy.
If those are referring to her feelings at all.
Stuff happens, and Kaede falls sick, which is very bad. Why? We all know that if there are 3 phases of anime health:
1) Perfectly fine.
2) Minor illness.
3) Death.
And so putting Kaede at level 2 (they call in a doctor, too?) we find out that it's one of them sicknesses that lasts about an episode until she gets better through more attention by Rin.
She needs to get sick more often, then.

And in the meantime Nerine ends the life of many innocent chicks. I have a feeling that omelettes are going to become a running gag, kind of like panty shots and resulting innuendo. That quote's from Nerine, by the way, who doesn't seem able to operate anything. She appears to be the smart-with-no-sense type; although she didn't have any problems with the finals such mysteries as cooking lay beyond her grasp.
But the real chef here is not Sia, but the Shocking Asa Shigure (as named)! What is more surprising than that is how embarrased she seems of that title and adoration. Asa looked like the last person to be caught acting like Hisui (Tsukihime), but perhaps she has more character than the genki girl who beats the crap out of Rin...
She seems to be the only one aware of Kaede, though.
Primula continues to be mysterious and quiet, having a scene where she picks plants for no reason. It turns out that it's a medicine recipe as her medicine makes Kaede 'all better.' At least, we can assume it's the medicine and not magic, but who really knows?
There's another earthquake, flipping the lights off and on for no good reason. I really want to say these are more than a plot device, perhaps foreshadowing for episodes to come but I have no concrete evidence for that. Maybe it's just time for more Kaede glomping.
Luckily her melancholy seems to be over for now at the end of this episode but the signs of unrest are beginning to show in the harem, Rin should be watchful...
-CCY
| [+/-] |
The Queue |
This post's just a little list of all the anime I have watched, am watching, or have yet to watch, just for reference. I've reorganized it as sort of a tier list so you can see my preferences and thoughts on each show as well. I think it says a lot about my tastes and who I am.
Shows in bold I'm currently watching, shows in italics I should watch but are currently not for some reason (or I have it as low priority), and plaino font shows have been completed.
Positions subject to change if a show jumps the shark or uh...dives under the shark? You know what I mean.
Tier 1: The defining works
Cardcaptor Sakura (Know your roots. This is where it all began, in an innocent little magical girl show that captured anime viewers everywhere. And I'm not ashamed a bit about it. I believe it would still be good today.)
Kanon 2006 (The anime of the post-CCS viewing period for me. AIR was great. Kanon obliterated it. Maybe it's because the characters were more endearing. Maybe it's because there was more time to develop the plot. But in any case, Kanon really struck home, and I stand by my fanboying unrelentingly.)
Tsukihime *Visual Novel* (Read before AIR, before Kanon, before any other modern anime. Opened a gateway to the land overarching plots where every character had an emotional story to tell. Never knew how much a work of fiction could affect you before this.)
Tier 2: Ones that'd I'd recommend anyone to see
AIR (What can I say, I'm a KyoAni whore. Manly tears are very OK. The show that made me tear up more than anything. And with the Summer specials, it makes you smile too.)
Azumanga Daioh (Easily digestible, universally understood humor that anyone can enjoy. Great in short stints, although not marathonable.)
The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya (I'm not completely overboard for Haruhi - Nagato, maybe - but it's a very good series that is 'different' in a sense. It's one of those things that you can't understand by reading about it; unless you count the light novels.)
Tier 3: Very good, but not for everyone
Clannad (5/24 complete; Key and KyoAni bias hasn't failed me yet. A bit 'been there', but I blame Fuuko. Dribble, shoot~ and a miss?)
Gambling Apocalypse Kaiji (5/? complete; a guys' show for once that's a great mindgame-like fest about a bunch of down-on-their-luck delinquents fighting for financial survival.)
Kagetsu Tohya *Visual Novel* (A great example of a funny and serious visual novel, but without knowing Tsukihime it'll fall a bit flat.)
KimiKiss Pure Rouge (4/12? complete; a down-to-earth multi-relationship romance show that is refreshing to watch - even if you can see the pairings coming.)
Lucky Star (Funny and cute, but if you're anti-moe, anti-KyoAni, or maybe just not into Japanese culture enough you'll hate it.)
Myself;Yourself (6/12? complete; a somewhat bread-and-butter visual novel adaptation with strong characters and a feel of 'more than the sum of its parts')
Minami-ke (4/? complete; a funny slice-of-life with romance aspects, and a cast that feels like it should be Slice of Life All-Stars)
School Days (Story's a complete trainwreck but you would never think a trainwreck would be so fun (or funny, sometimes) to watch. Presentation is great, music is great. Don't watch if you hate hating characters.)
Shuffle! (The first half drags almost as hard as D.C., and there's almost too much fanservice - and don't mention Memories - but the final half is quite captivating and redeems the series.)
sola (An interesting mix of harem/romance and action, which comes off quite well. A very good dramatic work, but lots of holes as a fictional work)
Tokimeki Memorial ~only love~ (What got me back into anime again, which is my highest praise for an otherwise bread and butter harem romance...with a bit of Akiko's jam to spice things up. Doesn't reinvent the wheel but uses it well.)
Tier 3.5: Yes, I need more tiers.
Da Capo (it's a bit of generic harem at time, and it's a bit filler-ish much of the time, but there are good characters and quite redeeming moments)
Da Capo Second Season (Even slower at the original at times, and Aisia is annoying as all hell; but D.C.'s great characters and character drama carry it through to a passable ending.)
ef ~a tale of memories~ (3/? complete; A trippy visual novel adaptation from shaft; the characters are interesting and the story is interesting but it's very confusing when watched with other anime.)
Nanatsuiro Drops (A great heartwarming show in the vein of Cardcaptor Sakura; romance that pokes a little fun at magical girls as well.)
Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei (9/12 complete; great dark humor and amusing references, but it's losing momentum. Too much off-kilter fanservice, maybe?)
Tier 4: Shows I'd like, but you probably wouldn't
Aria (2/many complete: the Nothing Happens of nothing happens shows, but it has a good feel.)
Code-E (Meganekko, dojikko, romance, case closed. A slow show, which means it's relaxing and entertaining to watch. Drags very hard at times though, and the ending is nonexistant.)
Kanon 2002 (A decent show, but everybody looks silly, Yuuichi's a jerk, and it gets absolutely hammered by Kanon 2006.)
Lunar Legend Tsukihime (As an anime, it's pretty good. As a Tsukihime fan, it's unforgivable.)
Tier 5: Passable shows; average with not much to say
Da Capo II (3/12? complete; fairly dull start first three episodes, but that's the D.C. way. I pray it improves.)
Doujin Work (Smirk-inducing funny and Tsuyuri is awesome, but nothing standout, cheaply made, and short. Not enough time to make an impression.)
Hidamari Sketch (1/12 complete; some appealing aspects to it but it sort of just Teflon-ed off me so far. May change with time.)
Potemayo (1/12 complete; well, it's funny, yeah, and it's cute, yeah, but I don't know. Maybe comedy isn't too much my forte; at least on its own.)
Shakugan no Shana II (5/24? complete; Shana's a good series but this isn't her at all. Too much faux drama, not enough good romance or action. OP rocks more than the show.)
Wangan Midnight (2/26 complete; My first racing anime to be honest, a good idea and less hax than Initial D, but hampered by ugly art and slow release.)
Tier 6: Forgettable
D.N.Angel (One of the few anime in the dead period between CCS and TokiMemo. Not much to say about it; it's not horrible, but the more I look at it the more I see generic yaoi bait.)
To Heart 2 (6/12 complete; one of the first I started upon getting back into anime, but as you can tell, I still haven't finished it. That should tell you how much I care.)
Unrated: To watch
5cm Per Second (R1 licensed; heard lots of good stuff about it and seems up my alley.)
Canvas 2 (Episodes downloaded; reccomended as another eroge/harem adaptation)
Ever17 *visual novel* (Needs to be bought; heard it's better than Tsukihime.)
Genshiken (R1 licensed; the manga seemed like an appealing take on otaku life)
Hayate the Combat Butler (Episodes downloaded; the manga was decent, if not a bit too guy-orientated.)
Higurashi a.k.a. When They Cry (R1 licensed; What is it? I don't know. That's why my job is to find out.)
Honey & Clover (R1 licensed, so close!; another good romance store, it seems)
Maple Story (Airing fall 2007; for laughs, I want to see an entire series of level grinding)
Moetan (Episodes downloaded; I'm more scared to watch this with every passing episode)
ONE (Episodes downloaded; it's a Key, er, Tactics VN adaptation, but heard it was junk. Looks it)
ONE *visual novel* (English patch released; me wants)
Shakugan no Shana (R1 licensed, movie watched, manga / light novels read; had some good existential stuff in the beginning, and the fights / romance seem nice.)
Sketchbook ~full colors (Episodes downloaded; some slice-of-life thingy)
-CCY (9/5/007)
4/22/2007
| [+/-] |
To Heart 2 - Episode 6 (Ruuuuuuuuuuuuu) |

And so it's back to everyone's other eroge harem show (technically), To Heart 2.
In episode 6 we find, as usual, the introduction of a new character. This time it's pink-haired Ruuko , who makes her appearance in typical sickly-girl fashion by passing out in front of the main character Taka-kun.
As usual, our protagonist with nothing better to do takes her out for a meal in the park, where there is no time in wasted in hinting she is not quite normal. Insert head-knuckle.
Ruuko spreads across many tropes in her episode, proving to be a foreigner (an alien, for that matter), a transfer student, a cat lover, one of them cutesy third-person speakers, and quite clearly the role of the mysterious girl. Come to think of it I've watched the full episode and I don't know her first name or why she's here.
She says about coming to observe the planet U and all the Us within it (I wonder if this will be elaborated on) but that's about the only line that gives her much backstory. She does some supernatural neato stuff like pwning a tree in order to save Meow that cat, though.
This episode is remarkably more continuous than many of the other episodes in that you
see more than one girl throughout the episode.
For example, Konomi shows up to spout a real naive line about karma and stuff. I see
this as a bit of characterization and find it cute how childish Konomi still is.
And then she goes away and we get a lot of Yuuji, who deserves more screen time being
tortured by Tama-nee, who appears for 5 seconds in this episode to do just that. Library/class rep girl who's name I've already forgotten plays a role in this episode by staring at Taka a lot, usually because of the weirdness of the transfer student from the 3rd planet in the 47th whatever that hangs around Taka. Also, she plays an overenthusiastic role in finding a seat for Ruuko, which as expected would be right next to Taka. Amusingness ensues as Ru shows a blatant disregard for social patterns on earth. Maybe a bit predictable but amusing.
Everyone's favorite blackmailer Karin shows up suitably excited by the oddness of the mysterious transfer student and sends Taka out on a recon (stalker) mission. It seems the 'you groped me, guilt guilt' gag will never get old, although I must say that I laughed at how fond Karin sounded when she recollected the scene.
Of note here is that "this and that" is supposedly Japanese for whatever innuendo you can come up with that means 'sex'. Certainly Karin is stretching the truth a bit and any day now she might end up claiming to bear Taka's child.
Also, how come nobody ever questions if Karin's devices actually work? I was a bit suspicious, at least.
The drawing scene was a bit odd as for some reason, although everyone was rushing to the roof see Ruuko's strange art on the school grounds, when Taka finally got to her there was no one up there. Lazy artists or short attention span; you decide.
Also, those drawings smacked of Haruhi, but nowadays what doesn't?
Not sure of the relation of the cat to Ruuko yet (if there's anything out of the ordinary), but the cat was an amusing plothole as Taka pulled the 'there's no way it could show up' card to produce the cat out of nowhere. This led to Taka's flagrant ignorance of animal abuse rules and the subsequent Kanon stunt the cat pulls by jumping over the fence.
Unfortunately, there was no truck and no human kitsune here.
All in all this episode wasn't horribly exciting and I found myself wishing for more Lucky Star or TokiMemo subs throughout the episode but I can't really call this a waste of time. To Heart 2 is a good series for those who like fluff, as it's not horribly complex nor emotional, just sort of happy happy.
I appreciate the sudden influx of supernatural with Karin and Ruuko, but I'm hoping that some sort of explanation or connection behind all this U-Foe stuff is waiting in the wings, rather than "Karin likes UFOs. See, there's one! Yay, Karin!"
But, yay Karin!
Next time on TH2: More Konomi, which appears rather early for a repeat of a character as the focus of an episode. I'm still waiting for the gamer twins who appear in the opening... also, since it's a stargazing event I can probably expect a lot of Karin along the way too, with maybe a bit of Ruuko. We'll see.
-CCY
4/21/2007
| [+/-] |
Shuffle - Episode 4 (my omelette, punk) |


Shouldn't I just skip like 16 episodes of Shuffle! and just go forward to sad Kaede time and blahblahblah ending stuff with green-hair? That's really, what I know about this series and why I keep watching it. Just to see how Kaede can compare with emo-Nayuki for the sad rejected (despite 'First Girl Wins' trope) character.
But then again, I'd be missing out on 16 viewings of that spiffy opening. I tend to judge anime a lot by their openings - or the music at least. The animation in Shuffle!'s OP isn't anything out of the ordinary - it looks to have spoilers x 1000000 in there but I can't really say for sure yet. Also, it lacks dancing :P But it's a decent rock-ish song that's been stuck in my head for a few days now.
And considering it pushed out Lucky Star's 1 minute 10 seconds of caffeinated karaoke, I call that impressive.
Shuffle! continues to speed onwards at rapid pace. While the supernatural aspects of the story haven't seems to kick in yet they are readily apparent as Nerine (blue hair) proves she shouldn't be messed with. Man, harems sure are dangerous these days.
Also, collateral damage, hmm?
I was more surprised at the fact that this wasn't a continuation of Sia's arc, as it so seemed to be at the end of last episode. Not sure if this may end up pulling a To Heart 2 where it focuses on all the girls for an episode and then launches into something...different.
Also, there's something about that cat. It's everywhere. Originally, I thought it was part of Primula's arc, as she shows up with it in the OP, but with it in the eyecatch, alone in the OP by itself and now in the flashback Nerine, it might be more all-encompassing than I thought. It remains to be seen if it grants 3 wishes also.

Shuffle! has done away with most of the angsting of most romance shows, in that the female characters all have an established huge gigantic crush on Rin. There' s no 'do I like him, do I not' (see: Syaoran from CCS) here. Still, they didn't have to resort to the obviousbat here.
Also, about the second picture there, the girls in Shuffle have too many names, I swear. We've got Kaede/Kae-chan, Shigure/Asa-sempai, Sia, Nerine/Rin-chan (and I thought that was a translation error), and Primula/Rimu/that one thing she was called in the second episode. Geez.

An oddity here is the flashback in this episode...to all of one minute ago. I understand that this line certainly be an important one, but I doubt we would forget it that fast. As long as it doesn't end up like Nayuki's snow bunny, showing up 20 times in an episode, I'll forgive it. Besides, I figure Rin should already know the status of everybody in his harem (infatuated beyond belief). The line in question here also reminds me of 'infinity plus one'.
What is it with anime and cooking scene? I must be missing the whole 'make a lunch box for your beloved' scene in America. Shame. But this feels like the tenth time I've heard this line, and I'm not sure what I can attribute it to as 90% of the romance anime I've watched have a cooking episode.
Not the brightest line to say to a girl with a knife. I was surprised how Rimu seemed to confront Rin so readily after glomping him for an entire episode 2 episodes back. Not sure if it's because she doesn't know personal skills, or if she's bitter? Abandoned from Rin's childhood (think Mai, or pretty much any other Kanon girl for that matter)?
And the iconic line from this episode. The whole omelette scene made me burst out laughing. Turns out harem leads have a way to stand up for themselves after all, if only in trivial situations.
Also: why does Midoriba get to partake in all the bento awesome, being the resident ecchi? His line where he gets a different lunch from a girl every day, supposedly. Maybe it's because he, along with Rin and the harem's parents, is the only guy with a face that is not entirely fugly.
-CCY
